Are Jehovah’s Witnesses a Cult?

If they were honest how would they vote?Report by Richard E. Kelly

I am often asked, “Are Jehovah’s Witnesses a cult?” In fact – it’s likely that many Jehovah’s Witnesses may wonder and ask themselves that question every time they go to meetings at their Kingdom Hall or to a large convention in some distant city.

When I am asked to respond to that question, my preference is to suggest that they should try to find the answer for themselves. To help start that discovery process for those of you who may wonder what the facts suggest, I want to share the following information:

Cults have two distinguishing characteristics:

  1. A significant opposition to critical thinking with an insistence on blindly following a set of dogmatic ideals, all the while giving members the false sense of self-determination and free choice.
  2. Isolating their followers with threats of heavy penalties, including shunning and death, for “apostasy” and deviating from their “truth.”

TakeBackJanja Lalich, from her book Take Back Your Life – Recovering from Cults and Abusive Relationships (a must-read for all JWs and ex-JWs), defines a cult “as a group or movement that exhibits great or excessive devotion to some person, idea, or thing, using coercive methods of persuasion (undue social influence) and control (e.g., isolation from former friends and family, powerful group pressures, information management, suspension of individuality or critical judgment, promotion of total dependency on the group and fear of leaving) to advance the goals of the group, with actual or possible detriment to members, their families and the local and world community.”

According to Janja Lalich and Michael Langone, a psychologist and the executive director for ICSA (International Cultic Studies Association at icsahome.com), several characteristics* that may be present to a greater or lesser degree, and which help to distinguish cults from other communities or groups are:

  • Members are expected to be excessively zealous and unquestioning in their commitment to the identity and leadership of the group. They must replace their own beliefs and values with those of the group.
  • Members are manipulated and exploited, and may give up their education, careers and families to work and study excessively long hours at group-directed tasks, such as proselytizing, reading and studying literature produced by the group, and spending time in group meetings.
  • Harm or the threat of harm may come to members, their families, and/or society due to inadequate medical care, psychological and emotional child abuse, policies that treat pedophilia as a sin and not a crime, etc.
  • They regard their belief system as the truth and all other belief systems are false and originate with the devil.
  • Questioning, doubt and dissent are discouraged or even punished with extreme shunning.
  • The group is elitist, claiming a special exalted status for itself and its members.
  • The group has a polarized, us-versus-them mentality.
  • The leadership is not accountable to any authorities, as opposed to mainstream and benevolent religious denominations where a system of accountability is in place.
  • The leadership induces feeling of shame and/or guilt in order to influence and control members.
  • The group is preoccupied with bringing in new members.
  • The most loyal members (the “true believers”) feel there can be no life outside the context of the group. They believe there is no other way to be, and often fear reprisals to themselves or others if they leave—or even consider leaving—the group.
  • Members are expected to devote inordinate amounts of time to group and group-related activities.
  • When it is properly reported in the news that the group is guilty of violating the basic human rights of its members or ex-members, the group’s leaders report such news as persecution and lies to its followers, the work of apostates and the devil. The leadership will never take responsibility for its mistakes or harmful policies.

So are Jehovah’s Witnesses a cult? How would you vote?

* While the meaning of the word “cult” will vary dramatically with most people in the general public, the characteristics unique to cults are not the least bit ambiguous, at least not for the experts in the field. In fact, the aforementioned cult characteristics cited by Lalich and Langone are duly acknowledged by Steven Hassan, a mental health counselor and author of three books about cults; Alexandra Stein, Ph.D. and a writer and lecturer specializing in the social psychology of cults; Gillie Jenkinson, a psychotherapist; Alan Scheflin, a retired professor of law; and Jon Atack, a well-known writer and lecturer on cult characteristics.


Link to Take Back Your Life: Recovering from Cults and Abusive Relationships


Comments

Are Jehovah’s Witnesses a Cult? — 37 Comments

  1. JWs will deny this. That’s because no one will ever say they are in a cult. It’s not until you leave that you can see how you were deceived, manipulated and coerced into acting so badly.

  2. If it walks like a Duck and talks like a Duck it is a DUCK! Yes, the JW’s fit the majority if not all the qualifications of a cult. Of course they won’t say that but many within the Organization have told me thy struggle with the Idea that they are a Cult. When I was a Active JW and I was a TRUE BLUE JW it always bothered me that we were not “ALLOWED” to question anything the WT said or taught. Even though privately many were questioning the policies and teachings. If the WT had a tract record of being correct on anything that would ne 1 thing but they have the worst tract record of any religion on predictions and prophecies. Not 1 thing they JW’s have taught or prophesied has come true yet they demand 100% obedience to a failed teaching.

  3. Having been brought up in this cult I can say definitely it is a cult. It took years of counselling to get me straight and I still have aftershock moments 30 years on. My family is in shreds and apparently that our fault for leaving. It’s a very dangerous group.

  4. No different from the “Moonies” Scientologists, Jim Jones,Hare Krishnas etc. Just different approaches and different teachings. Thy all demand OBEDIENCE and no critical thinking. In fact the JW’s are worse in many ways bc they will not allow a family member to associate with someone who has left the WT for any reason. It is a Cult.

  5. I fully endorse Jose Lopez and others. They once described themselves as a Happy People but nothing could be further from the truth.

  6. Cult no. Different and separate yes. They would have to be apart from this world. They would have to think differently and act differently. Anything in opposition to this world has been and always will be demonized because this world is ran by demons. In order for anyone to continue on a righteous path, one has to understand that a change in thinking is part of the journey, and that change in thinking must always be centered around the fact that divination from Jehovah will fair in consequences. Both Jesus and the Bible are ridiculed on a hourly bases, so why would the Witnesses not be. Preach on God’s people!!!!

    • Different yes – as people that produce offspring to become mini preachers that are well below them in the hierarchy of the religion. Being one of those offspring to a so called elder I am in a position to say what an atrocious life I had until I left – it’s been said so many times – if this is the truth than I do not want to live ever.

    • I was a JW for many many years. I have one question for Lavisha, “Why would an individual not speak to their parents who have chosen another way of life, shunning them as dead, when the Bible says “Honor your father and mother that it may go well with you”? Pls. answer that.

    • Lavisha,you say this world is ran by demons. Then The watchtower society is run by demons also. When children have been abused, they say “it’s a sin before it’s a crime”, and they attack the victims. It happened to my child. what if that were your child? Your a prime example of cognitive dissonance.

  7. Lavisha… your comment to Preach On God’s people is a noble one. In all honesty though the JW message continually changes right? I mean they were preaching that WITHOUT A DOUBT the generation that saw the events of 1914 would not pass away before Armageddon came and the New World would be here. People gave up lives and careers and jobs and families and other necessary fulfilling lives to go “PREACH” that message? The inside of the Awake magazine stated for over 45 years that message. Now that it is proved false and untrue they changed the message and the meaning of what a generation is? That is just one message they changed. How about the F&D slave? Now it is only 7 men on the GB. For many years it was ALL of the anointed at any time collectively? How about Joining the United nations? As they Identified it as the Wild Beast of Revelation but yet they voluntarily joined up with them
    and then made excuses about it?

    How about that Jesus came invisibly in 1914? or that 607 BCE is an inaccurate unbiblical year that Jerusalem was destroyed while all other scholars feel it was 586 BCE? Is there message also to protect the Religion but not the Victim in Child Molestation? So what is the message they are preaching? It changes so often a person really does not know.

    They have been wrong 100% of the time on any predictions they made and have NEVER been accurate 1 time. I have never seen or read where the WT apologized to anyone for their duff and erroneous prophecies. Or for telling people back since the 1960’s do not get an education bc you will never have a chance to use it. Just preach and make converts The End is near! The End is imminent. How sad and how wrong. Their message is a confusing one that changes with the wind. 1914 is a fallacy and Jesus did not return that year. Thw entire religion is a cult.

  8. They are reviving their god Jehovah… doing what it used to do before it died like any other gods of ancient world: Dagon, Asherah, Zeus, Jupiter and son on. Jehovah is now fighting worshipers of its sons Jesus and Satan (today’s god of the world) and Mary. That’s why JWs are a dangerous cult… Thinking they are “SPIRITUAL ISRAEL”, they are imitating ancient Jehovah’s Witnesses in their sexual prouesses and apostate killings…

  9. Much said and done to expose the Evil Watchtower’s control over peoples’ thinking, emotions, actions. How and what knowledge have those set free acquired to realize God in Truth, Justice, Rightiousness? Because there IS God who knows Us All, each and everyone, and without partiality and knowable through the Book of Creation/Created and our consciences. We are born with knowledge varified by our spirit in harmony with The ONE that there is no greater.
    Not to preach but to encourage to seek and find Our Way in associate with The One and Only God for a better life now and all future generations.
    Let us offer to share better than the lies, deceptions of religions, politics, most man-made systems. We need blessings not continued curses.

  10. I was in the Cult for 49 years. My wife was born into it and got out after 52 years. We are now Born Again Christians and follow the real Truth…the Lord Jesus/Yeshua as the only way, the only truth and the only life.

    For years I had an uneasiness about the teachings and we were told it would be Armageddon by 1975 and our Kids would never grow up in this System. Our oldest daughter is now 46 and has 2 grown up Kids who are 20 and 18 years old.

    We now live in Cyprus and run a small Christian Church in our house and love every minute of it….we feel so free of guilt and fear of displeasing that false deity J…….H who is actually a god of Freemasonry and Witchcraft…

    The Watchtower religion actually work against Yeshua/Jesus Christ and have never once bent/bowed the knee to the name Above every other name in heaven, or earth or under the earth Philippians 2.

    When the Apostle Paul was blinded on the road to Damascus, the Lord Yeshua (not J……..h) said Why are you persecuting ME? There was nothing about the false god mentioned above.

    The so called name of God the Father is never used in the Greek…..so why use that name? It is because of the root of the occult that the Tower is based upon.

    So glad we are set free and into the real Love of Yeshua our redeemer and Lord.

    Bless you all…

  11. David,thank you for that glorious testimony. It grieves me when people stop being JWs and turn their backs on true religion. There is still a ministry that is so pressing.

  12. Thank you James and Kobie, The Bible clearly states that it is belief in the Lord Yeshua that leads to Salvation. If we confess with our mouths that the Lord Yeshua is Christ our Saviour we will be saved. So why a ritualistic religion that controls peoples lives and saves no one?

    They actually keep people away from the Truth of the Lord Yeshua. The cults rule by fear and intimidation and that is why most stay in it. The Watchtower religion teaches its members to hate and judge others….where as Yeshua told his true followers that they are to Love their enemies and to Not judge anyone, Matthew 7.

    The corrupt leaders seem to think they are immune from this teaching of the Lord. We have learnt to BLESS and not curse. We even bless the people who call us Mentally Diseased..

    As Hebrews 12 tells us, that if we have bitterness, it will became a cause of stumbling and cause us problems…whatever we Sow we shall reap, so if we sow hate we will reap hate, if we sow judgment that is what we will also reap, but the WT do it all the time.

    We pity those still trapped in their clutches…we pray that the Tower will develop more and more cracks and that the true light of Yeshua will flood in and the genuine lovers of God will roll out.

    May the Lord bless you and keep you and keep on shedding the light in the dark

    places. Pastor David

  13. Just their blood policy alone – not even being allowed to possibly use your own blood for a critical surgery, and the resulting many thousands of deaths, including innocent little children – that in itself would have convinced me that it’s a cult, and a dangerous one at that. And, of course, the huge plethora of all the contradictions, flip-flops, and failed prophecies would have convinced me as well. All their arrogant, demeaning, and extremist policies, especially those involving their views on women – that also would have convinced me of their obvious cult status. But the combination of ALL of that together – well, how obvious could it possibly be? It just screams cult!

  14. 12 years a JW growing up lost my what would be my father over there belief system. We had four elders three were caught molesting there own children. My mother lived and breathed by there word even left my father for them. This can rune many lives yet it goes on. Cult or what ever it is EVIL! This is the world we live in. Who can you trust

  15. I lost my wife, my children,my home and life as I knew it for 25 years to watchtower. I see no difference between watchtower and Jim Jones. This is a sinister murderous cult that is every bit as evil as Hitler. For many years the consensus is that Hitler should have been stopped at Munich. What will be said about the apathetic failure to stop this cult.?

  16. 1.Charles Russell was a Freemason.
    2.JW Policy on Child Molestation.
    3.JW Policy on Blood.
    4.JW False Predictions.
    ANY QUESTIONS?

  17. I have been a baptized witness for five years and I have never been so miserable in all my life.

    I have recently found out that Gods name really isn’t Jehovah at all and that the organization has not been blind to this at all just to ashamed to tell the public that’s the sick part.

    My husband is completely brain washed I cant even convince him to read and do research on these people I want out but if I try to dis fellow myself he threatens me with divorce.

    The founder of this organization was a sick man and a part of the occult, I pray for my husband so that the creator will show him the light as myself.

    • My heart goes out to you. We were whole souled JW’s for 30 years. 45 members of my family cut us off when we left. They say we are “apostates, worthy of death”………much like the fundamentalist Muslims. So lots of research, as I see you have been doing, sign on to “Cedars” site for a balanced view as well as many of these excellent exJW sites. Pray for your husband. He may come around in time. Be strong, I send positive vibes from Canada

  18. Your definition of a cult pretty much includes most traditional religious organizations including Catholicism and Islam. I believe that people join religions to stiffle their natural or unnatural desires. Once in a position of authority, the commit the very “sins” that they sought to extinguish. Unfortunately this is all too human and they would act the same way whether in a different religion or secular position that affords them power over others

    • Frank. As a former Catholic and former JW I disagree with your thought that Catholicism acts lie a cult. Catholicism is very loose. If you go to church or not it does not matter. Very few Catholics are serious about their faith. You can pretty much do as you please as a Catholic. Maybe years ago Catholics were serious about their faith but few are anymore. Now the JW’s are definitely a Cult. They occupy all your time with meetings, mental propaganda, hundreds and hundreds of rules, the “ELDERS” are always watching touy, they are intent on you proselytizing day in and ay out. They monitor nearly every aspect of our life. Anyone NOT a Jw is considered bad association and even many KW’s if they are not 100% JW are considered bad to be with. If you decide to leave the religion they will punish you and not allow any of your JW friens to talk to you or even your family to talk with you.Jw’s a Cult YES! Catholics No.

      • Are you saying Roman Catholicism was once a cult and now it’s not? Or because you didnt have faith in your beliefs while Catholic negates those that are devoteand go to mass more than just on Christmas and Easter. Your argument that JW’s are cults I say, yeah ok asI personally believe most if not all religions are by the authors definition cults.

        • Frank. I am not sure if Catholicism was ever considered what we call a cult today. It very well could have been a cult in years past but I don’t think it ever had the day-day, total time consuming, Thought control that the JW’s have exercised and teach.type of religion. I went to Catholic school as a kid and there were many, many church members who were Catholic in name only. If they talked against the Catholic church or had different thought than the Church taught they were not “SHUNNED” or
          ostracized by mot other Catholics and that was when I was growing up in the 60’s and 70’s a much more conservative time than we have today.

          Most Catholics even today do not go to Church regularly but are still considered Catholics. You do not have to agree with any and all teachings of the Catholic Church to be a member. However for the most part you DO HAVE to agree with ALL WT teachings to be a JW. If you speak against it or express doubt you will be shunned and that is a sign of a true Cult.

          • Ok if you say so. But I can tell by your comments you were never a devote Catholic. Just because you’re baptized as a child and went to mass, the pope may consider you a Catholic but to be devote you would have to pick up your cross and follow Him. If you were Catholic were you ever in fear of your soul being lost to eternal damnation? No? Then its not a true comparison.You’re arguing that jw’s are a cult and I’m arguing both religions and most others are cults. You’re funny.

            And what is your opinion

        • Frank. Quite the opposite. I was a staunch Catholic Growing up as a kid until my late teenage years. I would go to Mass every Sunday and may times during the week. I was an altar boy and as a11 year old would get up at 4:30 am to go to do altar Boy service for 5:30am Mass at the convent for the Nuns at the school I went to in their private chapel.

          I always got an A in religion and seriously considered becoming a priest or at least a “brother”. I would collect funds for the “POPES” poor children fund by selling candy and cookies and give my Money to the Church for that to feed the hungry people of the world.

          Yes, I did fear of burning in a hell of torment for not being a “good enough” Catholic or I feared that I might skip Mass on a Sunday and then Die that day and go to hell bc that was considered a Mortal sin missing mass on your own unless you were SICK. I feared for my Parents bc they were not that serious of Catholics as I was and my Mom would use curse words and I always prayed for Goa to forgive her and my Dad also would not go to Mass regularly. I would go to confession almost every Saturday so my soul would be clean the next day to receive the Eucharist.

          IN a similar way the JW’s and Catholics teach fear. The JW’s do not believe in Eternal damnation in Hell fire but they teach eternal destruction at Armageddon and no chance of eternal life if you are not a JW. Also, they both make you feel that whatever you are doing it is never enough to please God.

          As a child I was taught by the nuns that the Catholics are the only true religion and I believed it at the time. Claiming all other Christian religions broke off from them and Peter was the first pope etc

          When I became a JW looking back they used the same approach but it was more hard and guilt driven and they tried to use scripture to back it up whereas the Catholics did not use much scripture.

          As mentioned previously I don’t think most Catholics care or worry about it anymore but the Majority of JW’s do and they are obsessed with it day in and day out. The JW’s are mind controlled by the WT Society and their entire culture is surrounded by other JW’s. JUst bc a religion uses eternal damnation as a teaching does not make them a cult. Most religions teach a reward ( eternal l life , 72 virgins,higher levels of Godness, oneness with God ) and most teach some kind of punishment for not obeying God or rejecting God.

  19. I’m going through the same situation as you Celeste with my wife. She’s 100% “In the truth” (I refuse to call it the truth anymore) & any attempt to raise my doubts/questions with her just makes her angry that I’m “Going against Jehovah”. I fell totally trapped in this situation as I pretty sure she’d probably leave me if I left. She went to the elders recently because I raised some apostate thoughts which ended up in a meeting with 2 of them. I just want her to see it for what it really is without her Watchtower Goggles on.

Share your thoughts . . .